Navier-Stokes finite-time blow-up proof credited to Buckmaster and Alpoge with AI help
원문을 읽지 못해 Hacker News 토론으로 요약했습니다
- Commenters report that the repo covers finite-time blow-up for the unforced Navier-Stokes equations, while OpenAI's earlier result needed a carefully designed external force.
- Commenters report that the certificate is not in the repository, and the paper says it will be released later.
- Commenters report that the bound check uses interval arithmetic at 128 bits of precision through the Arb library and FLINT, and that this code is also missing from the repo.
- Commenters report that Alpoge used AI in the work, and one commenter argues the model should be credited instead of the human authors.
Hacker News 의견들
I feel bad for Buckmaster and Alpoge. If the Anthropic millennium rumor hadn't been floating around, they'd probably have landed this without OpenAI scooping them.
Nah, I don't feel bad at all. OpenAI crediting the model instead of an author is fine by me. The model did most of the work, and I feel worse for Kevin Buzzard, who was doing the FLT Lean formalization by hand on a grant.
Feeling bad for him is a stretch. It's like an elite chess player using an engine and then complaining he lost to someone with a better engine.
This is the unforced version, and it's the one I always wanted. OpenAI's example needed a carefully designed external force, so this one feels more realistic.
I'd still love a physical demo of the blow-up. But Navier-Stokes isn't an exact model of real fluids, so any demo would just show where the model breaks.
Navier-Stokes is basically an effective field theory, so it breaks down at small scales where atoms matter. This result says the equations are wrong about impossible behavior, not that reality can blow up.
Release the transcripts and the development history, please. The repo has no certificate and the paper's source isn't in there either.
Biggest math day in a long while, with the generalized Riemann Hypothesis result landing the same day. I'd still want the details before calling it settled, since the interval arithmetic check isn't in the repo.